Permission to spend is a secret

5 minutes · 3 checks · On paper

A friend wants to pay you. Two paper cards lie on the table: Receive address and Private key. Which one should they get?

Use labels only for this practice, never a real address or secret.

Pause before reading on. Which card would you hand over, and why?

Give them the receive address. Think of a glass lockbox: anyone can see the coins and drop more through its slot. Only the right key lets someone take coins out. The address labels the box; it does not open it.

Bitcoin has no physical boxes. Your coins are pieces in the shared record, with conditions on spending them. For the ordinary payment here, spending needs proof made with the right private key: a secret number. Digital keys can be copied, so a copy gives someone else the same power to spend.

Your wallet uses the key to make a signature for a payment. Others can check that proof without seeing your key. Copying the signature does not give them the key or let them sign a different payment spending your coins.

A wallet is the app or device that keeps your keys. Keeping your own keys, instead of leaving them with a company, is called self-custody. Many wallets show you a list of 12 or 24 recovery words when you create them. These words can rebuild your keys. Anyone who gets them can spend your bitcoin.

A payer follows a receive-address label to a glass lockbox. A separate private-key path creates a signature that can be checked publicly. The shared record holds the coins; the wallet holds keys.
A practice example: an address lets someone pay you; your private key lets you spend.

Now picture your phone falling into a lake. Your coins stay in the shared record. The phone held keys, not coins. The words can restore access; your phone’s unlock code cannot replace them. Unlike Ana’s bank, there is no one who can issue a new login to your self-custody wallet. If you lose every way to recover the keys, the coins remain recorded, but you cannot spend them.

Back to the cards: give a payer the address; keep the spending secrets to yourself.

Check your understanding

1. Your friend wants to pay you. Which paper card do you give them?

  • AReceive address.
  • BPrivate key.
Show answer and explanation

The answer is A.

The address is the payment slot: it lets your friend pay you without giving them permission to spend your coins.

If you chose B:

The private key would let them spend your coins; give them receiving information instead.

2. A stranger copies the signature from one of your payments. Can they use it to sign a different payment that spends your coins?

  • ANo.
  • BYes.
  • COnly for small amounts.
Show answer and explanation

The answer is A.

The signature fits that payment without revealing your key; copying it does not let the stranger sign another payment.

If you chose B or C:

A public signature is not a copy of your secret key, whatever the amount.

3. Your phone with its self-custody wallet falls into a lake. Where are your coins?

  • AGone with the phone.
  • BDeleted from the shared record.
  • CStill in the shared record.
Show answer and explanation

The answer is C.

The app kept your keys, not your coins. Unlike Ana’s bank, nobody can give you a new login. Lose the phone and your recovery words, and nobody can give your coins back.

If you chose A or B:

Losing a phone deletes nothing from the shared record.

What you can now explain

A payer needs only your receive address; your keys and recovery words stay secret.

Your wallet keeps your keys, not your coins.

Next · Lesson 4

A crowd can’t make a broken rule count

Who checks whether a payment follows the rules?

Back to the map