A payment changes what each person can spend

5 minutes · 3 checks · On paper

You pay someone, and a number changes on your phone. What has actually changed?

Some money is cash. Most of the money you use is a number in your bank’s records. Your banking app shows you that number. The money itself is not on your phone.

Ana and Ben use the same bank. Ana has €10 and Ben has €0. Ana sends Ben €3, with no fee, and the transfer goes through:

AccountBeforeAfter
Ana€10€7
Ben€0€3

Both numbers changed together. The €3 left Ana’s balance and arrived in Ben’s. She can’t keep it and give it away.

Pause before reading on. Ana still has a screenshot from this morning showing €10. Can she use it to pay someone €8? Say why in your own words.

No. The bank’s record says €7, and the record is what she can spend. The screenshot is a picture of how things were.

Suppose Ana edits the screenshot so it says €100. She has changed a picture. She has not changed the bank’s record. Forwarding Ben the same payment message twice also does not make two completed transfers. A message and a payment are different things.

Ana's balance falls from ten euros to seven and Ben's rises from zero to three; a separate edited picture shows one hundred euros.
A practice example: the payment changes both balances. Editing a picture does not.

That distinction will matter when we turn to Bitcoin. Computers are very good at copying information. A money system needs a way to decide which changes count. Another copy of a payment message cannot mean another payment, or anyone could make more money by copying messages.

Explain it

Before moving on, finish this sentence in your own words: “An image of a balance is different from a payment because …”

Check your understanding

1. Ana’s €3 transfer completed. She forwards Ben the same payment message again. Has Ben been paid another €3?

  • ANo.
  • BYes.
Show answer and explanation

The answer is A.

Ben received another message about the same payment, not another €3.

If you chose B:

Sending the message again didn’t change either balance.

2. Ana drops her phone in a lake. What happens to her €7?

  • ALost with the phone.
  • BStill in the bank’s record.
  • CLocked in the app.
Show answer and explanation

The answer is B.

The app only showed the bank’s record. Her bank can give her a new way to log in.

If you chose A or C:

The €7 was never in the phone or the app. It stays in the bank’s record.

3. Ben sees “sending” on Ana’s phone. What still needs to happen?

  • ANothing more.
  • BThe bank changes both balances.
Show answer and explanation

The answer is B.

Sending is a request still on its way. Ben is paid when the bank changes both balances.

If you chose A:

“Sending” doesn’t yet mean “paid”.

What you can now explain

A payment changes the record of what each person can spend.

A screenshot or a copied message changes nothing in that record.

Next · Lesson 2

Copies do not create another payment

Next we will ask how Bitcoin handles two attempts to spend the same money.

Ben has ten copies of his message. Cara has one. Does Ben’s pile prove that his payment counts?

Back to the map